Order Baked Goods
From delicious Pies to Cinnamon Rolls, Sweet Bread Loaves & Quiche we have you covered! Use our handy online order form below to place your order directly with us. Payment is required for order to be processed.
Please allow at least 48 hours for your order. If you have questions or are looking for something you don’t see here please send us a message on Facebook or call (518) 709-4612.
NOTE: We are now accepting orders for baked goods for Christmas. DEADLINE DEC 18th! You can place your order online using the form below or print out the form at the link below and bring it into the store. Call the store with any questions. (518) 879-9442.
We make our pies from scratch using only fresh ingredients. Gluten Free Crusts Available upon request. Mini 5" pies sourced from Formisano's bakery in Saugerties, NY and delivered daily.
9" Fruit Pies $15.00
Available flavors: Apple, Blueberry, Cherry and Peach (available with either Crumb or Traditional toppings). Blueberry Peach (Lattice) & Blueberry Custard. Also available - our popular Strawberry Rhubarb pie with a special pastry star topping.
9" A little 'Somethin' Extra' Pies $15.00-$16.50
Available flavors: New Fashioned Apple Pie (w/ Grand Marnier!), Chocolate Cream, Key Lime, Fruit of the Forest (5 Fruit), Blueberry Peach, Peach Praline & Tollhouse.
9" Pecan Pies $16.50-$17.00
We offer 3 varieties: Classic Pecan , Chocolate Chunk Pecan and our most popular: Bourbon Pecan.
9" Pumpkin Pies $16.00
Available flavors; Classic Pumpkin & Fireball Whiskey Pumpkin (a pumpkin pie on cinnamon steroids!)
5" Formisano's Bakery Pies $3.50
Sourced from Formisano's bakery and delivered daily: Available flavors: Apple, Blueberry, Cherry, Peach, Pumpkin, Pecan, and Lemon
6" Hungry Chicken Small Pies $6.00
Individual portion sizes of our most popular large pies - perfect to share with someone special or to keep all for yourself!
Specialty Pies, Mini Loaves & Cinnamon Rolls
Carrot Cake $16.00
9" double layer carrot cake with cream cheese icing!
Bourbon Apple w/ Oatmeal Cookie Crumble $17.00
Bourbon Pecan $17.00
Fireball Whiskey Pumpkin $16.50
New-Fashioned Apple (w/ Grand Marnier) $17.00
Mini Bread Loaves $4.25
Carrot Cake (w/Cream Cheese Frosting), Apple Walnut, Browned-Butter Blueberry, Pumpkin, Cider Donut, Orange Glazed Cranberry, Lemon and Banana Nut Mini Loaves
Cinnamon Rolls $2.50 or 8 for $18
Large cinnamon rolls made in-house. Topped with vanilla icing.
Quiche $7.50 - $14.00
Extra-deep dish 6" mini quiche or a large 9" version - made with fresh eggs, roasted peppers & onions, american and parmesan cheese and either ham or bacon. Perfect for 1-2 people, depending on your appetite!