Order Baked Goods
From Pies & Cakes to Cinnamon Rolls, Sweet Bread Loaves, Cookies & Quiche we have you covered!
Our baked goods are crafted with care in our own scratch kitchen, ensuring the highest quality and freshness. With a team of skilled bakers and the use of premium ingredients, we guarantee a delightful taste experience. We ask for at least 48 hours notice when special ordering baked goods.
The Easter baked goods ordering deadline has passed. If you want something give the store a call and we’ll work to accommodate you.
Pies
We make our pies right here on site from scratch using only fresh ingredients. Gluten Free Pies available upon request. The small 5" pies sourced from Formisano's bakery in Saugerties, NY and delivered daily.
-
9" Fruit Pies $16-$17
Available varieties: Apple, Blueberry, Cherry and Peach (available with either Crumb or Traditional toppings). Blueberry Custard & our popular Strawberry Rhubarb pie.
-
9" A little 'Somethin' Extra' Pies $17 - $18
Available flavors: Cider Bourbon Apple w/ Oatmeal Cookie Crumble, , Chocolate Midnight, Fruit of the Forest (5 Fruit), & Tollhouse.
-
9" Cream Pies $17 - $18
Available flavors: Chocolate Cream, Key Lime & Lemon Cream - all topped with a generous helping of whipped cream!
-
9" Pecan Pies $17.50 - $18
We offer varieties: Classic Pecan , Chocolate Chunk Pecan and our most popular: Bourbon Pecan.
-
9" Pumpkin Pies $17-$20
Available flavors; Classic Pumpkin & Fireball Whiskey Pumpkin. This year we have added the special Pumpkin Cheesecake Pie!
-
5" Formisano's Bakery Pies $4.25
Sourced from Formisano's bakery and delivered daily: Available flavors: Apple, Blueberry, Cherry, Peach, Pumpkin, Pecan, and Lemon
-
6" Hungry Chicken Mini Pies $6.00
Individual portion sizes of our most popular large pies - perfect to share with someone special or to keep all for yourself!
Specialty Pies, Cakes, Mini Loaves & Cinnamon Rolls, Cookies & Cupcakes
-
Cheesecake (allow 3 days) $32 - $42
Indulge in our rich, creamy cheesecakes, made fresh with the finest ingredients. Whether you love classic flavors or something a little more indulgent, we have the perfect slice for you!
-
Cakes $20-$32
Discover why our Carrot Cake is a customer favorite—moist, perfectly spiced, and topped with creamy frosting (with no raisins!). Or explore our other delicious classics: 🍫 Boston Cream – Light, fluffy cake filled with rich pastry cream and topped with smooth chocolate ganache 🍏 Caramel Apple Upside Down – A warm, caramelized apple delight with a soft, buttery cake base 🍰 Chocolate Eclair – A decadent, layered dessert inspired by the classic pastry 🍫 Chocolate – A rich and indulgent favorite for every chocolate lover 🍏 Apple – A cozy, spiced cake bursting with fresh apple flavor 🍍 Pineapple Upside Down – A tropical treat with caramelized pineapple slices and a buttery cake base ❤️ Red Velvet – A smooth, velvety classic with just the right hint of cocoa ✨ New for 2025! ✨ 🥥 Coconut Layer Cake – A light, fluffy cake with layers of creamy coconut frosting and sweet coconut flakes Each cake is made fresh with quality ingredients and homemade care.
-
Cinnamon Rolls $2.50 - $16.00
Treat yourself to our perfectly pillowy, extra-large cinnamon rolls! Each roll is swirled with a generous layer of cinnamon-sugar goodness and topped with a rich, creamy glaze. Soft, fluffy, and irresistibly delicious, they’re perfect for breakfast, dessert, or any time you crave a sweet indulgence.
-
Sweet Bread Loaves $4.95
Indulge in one of our freshly baked sweet bread loaves—each approximately 5.75" x 2" x 3" and bursting with delicious flavor! Perfect for breakfast, a snack, or a sweet treat any time of day.
-
Quiche $7.50 - $14.00
Available in 6" Deep Dish or 9" pies. Our house quiche; roasted onion & peppers, cheese, meat of your choice (ham, bacon - or veggies only)
-
Cookies $16
Satisfy your sweet tooth with our freshly baked cookies! We offer mixed boxes by the dozen, available with or without nuts—or choose a single variety if you have a favorite. Our selection includes classic favorites like: 🍪 Chocolate Chip – A timeless treat with the perfect balance of chewiness and chocolatey goodness 🍏 Oatmeal Raisin – Hearty, soft, and full of comforting flavor 🥜 Peanut Butter – Rich, nutty, and melt-in-your-mouth delicious 🍂 Snickerdoodles – Soft, buttery, and coated in a sweet cinnamon-sugar blend 🍫 Chocolate Jumbles – A deep, chocolatey delight with just the right amount of sweetness 🍯 Molasses Cookies – Warmly spiced, soft, and packed with rich molasses flavor ✨ Sugar Cookies – Buttery, tender, and perfectly sweet
-
Cupcakes 3 for $8,12 for $30
Indulge in our freshly baked cupcakes, available in four classic flavors: 🍫 Chocolate – Rich, moist, and decadent 🍓 Strawberry – Light, fruity, and flavorful 🍦 Vanilla – A timeless favorite with a perfect balance of sweetness ❤️ Red Velvet – Smooth, velvety, and topped with luscious frosting